Tag: proofing

  • Sourdough Focaccia Won’t Puff: Why It Bakes Up Flat and Dense, and How to Fix It

    Sourdough Focaccia Won’t Puff: Why It Bakes Up Flat and Dense, and How to Fix It

    You pictured a tall, cloud-soft slab with a crackly oil-blistered top and a crumb full of big, irregular holes. What came out of the oven was flat, tight, and faintly bready — more cracker than pillow, with shallow dimples that barely held any oil. Flat focaccia is one of the most common sourdough disappointments, and the frustrating part is that focaccia is supposed to be the forgiving one. No shaping, no banneton, no scoring — just a wet dough in an oiled pan. So when it bakes up dense, it feels like the recipe lied to you.

    It didn’t. Focaccia that won’t puff is almost always a sign of one specific problem, and once you can read which one it is, the fix is simple. Let’s walk through the real causes in the order they actually happen, from most to least common, with the diagnosis and the fix for each.

    First, what a puffy focaccia actually needs

    All that height and all those holes come from one thing: gas trapped in a dough strong enough to hold it. Your starter ferments the dough and fills it with carbon dioxide; the gluten network and the water stretch around those bubbles like the skin of a balloon. Bake it in a hot oven and the trapped gas expands, the bubbles set, and you get that tall, airy, open crumb. Flat focaccia means one of three things went wrong: the dough never made enough gas (fermentation), the dough couldn’t hold the gas (weak or dry dough), or you knocked the gas out before it baked (handling). Everything below is a version of one of those three.

    A flat dense sourdough focaccia next to a tall puffy golden one with big bubbles, shown side by side
    Same dough, two outcomes. Flat and tight on the left, airy and tall on the right — the difference is almost always the proof.

    Cause #1: It was underproofed (by far the most common)

    If your focaccia is flat and the crumb is tight and gummy-dense rather than open, it almost certainly didn’t ferment and proof long enough. This is the number-one reason, and it’s especially common now that kitchens are cold. A sluggish winter starter plus a cool counter means the dough needs far longer than the recipe’s summer timeline to fill with gas — and most people pull the trigger too early because the clock said so.

    Focaccia proofs in two stages, and both matter. The bulk ferment (the first rise, before it goes in the pan) should leave the dough visibly expanded, domed, and jiggly, with bubbles showing on the surface and around the edges of the bowl. The second proof in the oiled pan should leave it puffy and wobbly, so a gentle poke springs back slowly and leaves a faint dent. If your dough looked flat and lifeless going into the oven, it will look flat and lifeless coming out.

    The fix: stop baking by the clock and start reading the dough. Give the bulk ferment as long as it needs to genuinely grow and bubble — in a cold kitchen that can be several hours longer than you expect. If you’re not sure whether you’re under or over, our guide to how long bulk fermentation should actually run walks through reading the dough instead of the timer. And if your starter itself is sluggish, that’s its own fix — a weak starter can double in the jar and still fail to lift a dough, which we unpack in why a starter that doubles still won’t raise your bread.

    Cause #2: The dough was too stiff and dry

    Focaccia is a high-hydration dough on purpose. All that water is what makes the crumb open, custardy, and tall; a stiff, dry dough bakes into something closer to a thick flatbread. If your dough felt like sandwich-bread dough — easy to handle, holding a neat ball, not sticky — it had too little water to ever puff the way focaccia should.

    This usually happens one of two ways: the recipe’s hydration was too low to begin with, or (more often) you added extra flour during mixing or folding because the wet dough felt alarmingly sticky and you wanted to tame it. That instinct is the enemy of focaccia. The stickiness is the recipe.

    The fix: aim for a genuinely wet dough — around 75–80% hydration for most focaccia — and resist adding flour. Instead of kneading, build strength with a few sets of stretch-and-folds in the bowl during the first hour or two: wet your hand, lift one side of the dough, stretch it up, and fold it over, rotating the bowl. This develops the gluten that traps gas without drying the dough out. A wet dough you strengthen with folds is what holds those big bubbles; a dry dough you kneaded stiff will always bake flat.

    A wet high-hydration sourdough focaccia dough being folded by hand, slack and bubbly in a glass bowl
    Focaccia dough should be wet, slack, and alive with bubbles. A stiff, dry dough never puffs — it needs the water.

    Cause #3: You dimpled too early and deflated it

    Those deep dimples are part of what makes focaccia focaccia — they hold pools of olive oil and create the signature dappled top. But timing matters enormously. If you pressed the dimples in while the dough was still slack and under-risen, you squeezed out the gas before it ever had a chance to inflate, and the dough had no time left to recover. The result bakes flat with sad, shallow dents.

    The fix: dimple late, not early. Let the dough do its full second proof in the oiled pan until it’s visibly puffy and jiggly, then oil your fingertips and press straight down to the bottom of the pan with a confident, gentle touch — you want to push oil into deep dimples without crushing the whole slab. Done at the right moment, dimpling redistributes bubbles rather than destroying them, and the dough springs tall in the oven. Being generally rough with a wet dough deflates it the same way; if yours tends to tear and collapse when you handle it, the gentle-handling habits in why dough tears instead of stretching carry straight over to focaccia.

    Cause #4: Not enough oil, or the oven wasn’t hot enough

    Focaccia is basically shallow-fried on its bottom and top by a generous slick of olive oil, and that oil does real work: it conducts heat into the dough fast, crisps the base, and helps the whole thing spring up and brown. A dry pan and a stingy drizzle give you a pale, tough, flat result even when the proof was perfect. The same goes for a cool oven — focaccia wants real heat to get that burst of oven spring before the crust sets.

    The fix: be generous with oil in the pan and on top — focaccia is not the place to count tablespoons. A well-oiled metal pan gives the best bottom crust and lift. And bake hot: most focaccia bakes at 450°F (230°C) or higher on a rack in the lower third of the oven, fully preheated. If your bakes always come out pale and under-risen, a weak or under-preheated oven may be stealing your oven spring, the same way it does for a boule — the steam-and-heat principles in getting real oven spring without a Dutch oven apply to the open pan too.

    Oiled fingertips pressing deep dimples into a puffy proofed focaccia dough with olive oil pooling in the dents
    Dimple only when the dough is already puffy and jiggly — press to the bottom of the pan without deflating the air you built.

    Cause #5: The dough was ice-cold going into the oven

    If you cold-proofed your focaccia overnight in the fridge (a great move for flavor and schedule), baking it straight from cold can blunt the rise. A fridge-cold dough is sluggish and tight; it needs to wake up and finish puffing at room temperature before it hits the heat, or it spends its oven time just thawing instead of springing.

    The fix: after a cold proof, pull the pan out and let it sit on the counter until the dough looks puffy, jiggly, and comes toward room temperature — often 1 to 2 hours in a cool kitchen — then dimple and bake. This warm-up-before-baking question comes up for every cold-proofed sourdough, and we cover the general rule in whether to bake sourdough straight from the fridge or let it warm first.

    A quick diagnostic, from the crumb

    Cut into a flat focaccia and the crumb tells you which problem you had:

    • Tight, gummy, close crumb with few holes → underproofed or a weak starter. Give it more time; fix the starter.
    • Dense but dry and bready, almost like a thick flatbread → dough too stiff. Add water, do folds instead of kneading.
    • Some big holes but an overall collapsed, deflated look → dimpled too early or handled too roughly. Proof fully, dimple late and gently.
    • Pale, tough, and flat all over → not enough oil or oven too cool. More oil, hotter oven.

    If you’re also getting wildly uneven results — big caverns in one spot, tight crumb in another — that’s usually uneven fermentation or shaping rather than a focaccia-specific issue, and it’s worth reading why sourdough gets huge holes in some spots and tight crumb in others.

    A tall golden sourdough focaccia fresh from the oven, deeply dimpled and glistening with olive oil, salt, and rosemary
    A hot oven and a well-oiled pan give you the crisp, blistered, deep-golden top that a cool oven never will.

    Get it tall next time

    Flat focaccia almost never means you ruined the dough — it means one link in the chain was short. Nine times out of ten it’s the proof: a cold kitchen and a cautious clock conspired to send an under-risen dough into the oven. Keep the dough wet, build strength with folds instead of flour, let both rises go until the dough is genuinely puffy and jiggly, dimple late and gently into a well-oiled pan, and bake it hot. Do that and the next one springs tall, with a crisp oily crust and a crumb full of big, irregular, custardy holes.

    A piece of sourdough focaccia torn open to show a tall airy open crumb with big irregular holes and a crisp crust
    The payoff: a tall, open, custardy crumb full of irregular holes — proof the dough was fermented and proofed all the way.

    Focaccia is one of those bakes that clicks the instant you watch what “puffy and ready” actually looks like — how wobbly the dough should be, how deep to dimple, how much oil is really enough. The full step-by-step sourdough focaccia, from the wet dough to the deep-dimple finish, lives on the LoafLovers YouTube channel, and our free sourdough troubleshooting guide has a printable proofing-check cheat sheet so you never send a flat one into the oven again. Keep it wet, proof it fully, and go bake the tall one.

    Related Reading

  • The Big Tunnel Under Your Sourdough Crust: What Causes a Hollow Flying Crust and How to Fix It

    The Big Tunnel Under Your Sourdough Crust: What Causes a Hollow Flying Crust and How to Fix It

    You pulled a beautiful loaf out of the oven. The crust is dark and blistered, it sang as it cooled, and you were already composing the photo. Then you cut into it and the knife drops through a dense slab of crumb into a giant hollow cavern right under the top crust. The crust has lifted off like a dome over an empty room. It is one of the most deflating moments in home baking, partly because the outside looked so promising.

    Bakers call this a flying crust, or sometimes tunneling. It is not a random accident and it is not ruined bread — it toasts perfectly well. But it is a clear signal that something went wrong between the mixing bowl and the oven, and once you know how to read it, the fix is usually straightforward. Let’s work through the real causes, from most common to least, and exactly what to change for each.

    What a flying crust actually is

    During the first few minutes in a hot oven, your loaf does most of its expanding. The outside sets into a crust while the inside is still soft and full of gas that is rapidly expanding in the heat. In a healthy loaf, that expansion pushes the whole structure up evenly — the crumb and the crust rise together and stay fused.

    A flying crust happens when the crust sets before the crumb underneath it has finished rising, or when there is already a large weak void sitting just below the surface. The top skin firms up, the gas below keeps expanding and pushing outward, and because the crumb can’t rise into the crust, it tears away instead. The gas collects in that gap, inflating it into the hollow dome you sliced into. In almost every case the root problem is one of two things: the dough was not ready, or the surface was too tight and too fast to set. Let’s separate them.

    Cause #1: The loaf was underproofed

    This is the single most common cause of a hollow under the crust, and it surprises people because underproofed dough feels so firm and promising when you load it. An underproofed loaf still has enormous rising energy left in it. When it hits the heat, it lunges upward all at once in a violent burst of oven spring. The crust can’t keep up, the dough tears internally, and the gas pools in one big cavity rather than distributing into an even crumb.

    The giveaway: a flying crust from underproofing usually comes with a dense, tight crumb below the gap, sometimes with a compressed band near the bottom. The loaf looks like it tried to explode upward and left the lower half behind.

    The fix: give the dough more time in bulk fermentation. Watch the dough, not the clock — it should grow by roughly 50 to 75 percent, feel jiggly and alive, and show bubbles along the sides and surface. Use the poke test to judge readiness before you ever shape or bake. A cool kitchen slows everything down, so if your dough has been sluggish, it almost certainly needs longer than your recipe’s stated time.

    Finger poke test on proofing sourdough dough in a banneton
    The poke test tells you whether the dough has fermented enough to avoid a hollow, underproofed bake.

    Cause #2: Big gas pockets trapped during shaping

    If you shape your loaf too gently and leave large bubbles trapped just under the surface, those bubbles become the seed of a tunnel. In the oven they expand faster than the surrounding crumb, merge together, and lift the crust clean off. You’ll often see this as a flying crust in a loaf that is otherwise well fermented — the crumb below is open and nice, there’s just a giant pocket up top.

    The fix: degas more deliberately during pre-shaping. You are not trying to flatten the dough into a pancake, but you do want to pop the biggest bubbles and redistribute the gas evenly. When you do your pre-shape and bench rest, give the round a firm pat to release any balloon-sized pockets, then let it relax before the final shape. Even, small bubbles in, giant trapped voids out.

    Cause #3: The surface tension was too loose — or too tight

    Shaping is a balancing act, and both extremes can cause tunneling. If your final shape is too loose and slack, the dough skin is weak and the expanding gas finds the path of least resistance — straight up into a dome under the crust. If your shape is too tight, you create a drum-tight skin that sets instantly in the oven and refuses to let the crumb rise into it, which also forces a separation.

    The fix: aim for a smooth, taut surface with real but not desperate tension. The dough should hold a round shape and have a tight skin you could bounce a crumb off, without you fighting it or tearing the surface. If you’re not confident here, our guide to shaping a boule with real tension walks through the hand motions that build an even skin — the same skin that rises with the crumb instead of flying off it.

    Hands shaping sourdough into a tight boule with surface tension
    Degassing and reshaping with real tension removes the large gas pockets that later balloon into a tunnel.

    Cause #4: Slack, over-hydrated dough that can’t hold its structure

    Very high-hydration dough is wonderful for an open crumb, but it is also more prone to flying crust, especially for newer bakers. A slack dough has less internal strength to resist the oven’s push, so the structure gives way at its weakest point — the thin layer just under the setting crust. Add a slightly under-developed gluten network on top of that, and you have a loaf primed to tunnel.

    The fix: back the hydration down by five to ten percent while you dial in your process, and build more strength with an extra set or two of stretch-and-folds during bulk. You want the dough to pass a rough windowpane and to hold a defined edge when you turn it out. Once your shaping and proofing are reliable at a moderate hydration, you can push the water back up with far less risk of a cavern.

    Cause #5: The crust set too fast — steam and scoring

    Sometimes the dough is fine and the problem is purely in the bake. If the top of your loaf blasts to a hard crust in the first few minutes — too little steam, or a surface that dried out during a long uncovered proof — it locks into place before oven spring finishes, and the still-expanding crumb has nowhere to go but away from it.

    Scoring matters here too. A single shallow score at a low angle gives the gas a deliberate place to escape and expand, so it vents through the ear instead of ballooning blindly under the crust. Too shallow, too timid, or no score at all, and the pressure has to find its own exit — often as a hollow dome or a blowout bursting from the side.

    The fix: bake with plenty of steam for the first 20 minutes — a lidded Dutch oven is the easiest way to guarantee it — so the crust stays soft and extensible while the loaf is still rising. Score decisively with one confident slash at roughly a 30-degree angle to create a controlled weak point. A crust that stays pliable long enough will rise with the crumb and stay married to it.

    Scoring a sourdough loaf at a shallow angle with a lame
    A shallow, angled score gives trapped gas a controlled exit instead of ballooning under the crust.

    How to diagnose your own loaf in 30 seconds

    Next time you cut a flying crust, read the clues instead of guessing:

    • Hollow dome plus a dense, tight crumb below? Underproofed. Ferment longer, judge by feel and the poke test.
    • Hollow dome but a nice open crumb elsewhere? A trapped shaping bubble. Degas and reshape more deliberately.
    • Loaf also spread wide and flat? Too little surface tension or dough too slack. Tighten the shape, lower hydration, build more strength.
    • Great interior but a thick, hard, early-setting crust? A baking problem. More steam, a decisive score, don’t let the surface dry out.

    Most flying crusts I see come down to the same quiet pair: a loaf shaped a touch too gently and baked a touch before it was truly ready. Fix those two and the crust stops flying. You’ll know you’ve cracked it when you slice in and the crust is pressed tight against an even crumb, no cavern, no slab — just bread all the way through.

    Want to see exactly what a well-degassed shape and a proper score look like in real time? The full visual walkthrough of fixing a flying crust — shaping, poke test, and scoring — lives on the LoafLovers YouTube channel, and you can grab our free sourdough troubleshooting guide to keep the symptom-and-fix chart next to your bench. No perfect loaves, just the ones that finally stopped tunneling.

    Related Reading

  • The Poke Test: How to Tell When Sourdough Is Ready to Bake

    The Poke Test: How to Tell When Sourdough Is Ready to Bake

    You are standing over the banneton with an oven that hit temperature ten minutes ago, and you have no idea whether to bake. Pull the loaf too soon and it bakes up tight, pale, and dense with a splitting side. Leave it too long and it slumps into a flat, gummy pancake the second you turn it out. The final proof is where a lot of good dough quietly goes wrong – not because the recipe failed, but because the timing was a guess.

    The fix is not a better clock. It is a ten-second read you do with one floured finger. Here is how to run the poke test properly, how to read every result, and what to do when it tells you something you did not want to hear.

    A shaped sourdough loaf proofing in a floured banneton on a wooden counter
    The moment every baker second-guesses: is it ready, or not?

    Why the clock lies to you

    Most recipes give a final proof as a range – “1 to 3 hours at room temperature” or “overnight in the fridge.” Those numbers are a starting point, not a verdict. Fermentation speed depends on things that change from bake to bake: dough temperature, how strong and recently fed your starter was, hydration, the type of flour, and how warm your kitchen happens to be that day. A dough at 78F can be ready in half the time of the same dough at 68F.

    So when you bake by the clock alone, you are really betting that today’s conditions match the day the recipe was written. They rarely do. The dough itself is the only reliable timer, and the poke test is how you ask it directly.

    How to do the poke test correctly

    The test is simple, but small mistakes make it lie. Do it like this:

    • Flour your fingertip. Dip your index finger in flour so it does not stick and drag the surface. A sticky finger tears the skin of the dough and gives you a false read.
    • Press about half an inch deep. Aim for the side of the dough or a spot near the edge, not dead center, so a small dent will not ruin your final loaf. Press gently and steadily – you are making a shallow well, not punching through.
    • Pull your finger straight out and watch. The whole answer is in how the dent recovers over the next two or three seconds. Do not poke and immediately walk away; the recovery speed is the data.

    That is the entire technique. The skill is in reading what happens next.

    A floured finger pressing a shallow dent into proofed sourdough dough
    Flour the finger, press about half an inch deep, then watch the dent recover.

    Reading the three results

    There are three things the dent can do, and each one is a clear message.

    Springs back quickly and fully – underproofed. If the indent bounces right back and nearly disappears, the dough still has fermentation left in it. The gluten is tight and the gas has not built up enough. Bake now and you will get a heavy, close crumb and often a dramatic burst up one side where the trapped pressure forces its way out.

    Springs back slowly and leaves a slight dent – ready. This is your window. The dent fills in gradually over a couple of seconds but does not vanish completely, leaving a soft, shallow depression. The dough feels aerated and a little jiggly but still holds its shape. That slow, partial recovery means the gluten is relaxed and well aerated but still has structure to spring in the oven. Bake it.

    Does not spring back at all – overproofed. If the dent just stays there, or the surface sighs and deflates around your finger, the dough has gone too far. The gluten has weakened and can no longer trap gas or hold a tall shape. It will spread flat and bake gummy. This is the result you most want to catch early.

    Three proofed dough rounds showing under, ready, and over proofed surfaces
    Underproofed springs back fast, ready recovers slowly, overproofed stays dented.

    Cold dough plays by different rules

    If you retard your shaped loaf in the fridge, do not expect the same lively spring. Cold dough is firm and slow, and a straight-from-the-fridge poke will always recover more sluggishly than room-temperature dough simply because it is stiff, not because it is overproofed.

    The practical move is to judge the proof before the dough goes cold. Get the loaf to a good ready-or-nearly-ready point at room temperature, then move it to the fridge, where the cold slows fermentation to a crawl and buys you a wide baking window – often 8 to 16 hours. When you pull it out, you are baking cold dough that was already at the right stage, which also scores far more cleanly. If you must judge a cold loaf, look more at overall volume and doming than at spring speed.

    Back it up with two more signs

    The poke test is reliable, but the best bakers never lean on a single signal. Cross-check it with two others:

    • Volume. A well-proofed shaped loaf has grown noticeably – roughly 30 to 50 percent larger, not doubled. Doubling at the shaped stage usually means it has gone too far.
    • Shape and jiggle. A ready loaf looks softly domed and relaxed, with a smooth, slightly bubbly surface, and it jiggles gently when you nudge the banneton. A dough that has spread wide and flat, with bubbles breaking the surface, has overproofed.

    When the poke, the volume, and the jiggle all agree, you can bake with confidence. When they disagree, trust the poke and the shape over the clock every time.

    Risen sourdough dough with a smooth domed jiggly surface in a bowl
    Back up the poke with volume and jiggle – three signals beat one.

    If you catch it wrong, do this

    The test only helps if you act on it.

    Underproofed? Give it more time. Leave the loaf somewhere warmer – the top of the fridge or near the oven – and re-poke every 20 to 30 minutes. There is no rush and no harm; you are just waiting for that slow, partial recovery to show up.

    Overproofed? Do not wait – baking now beats waiting for it to get worse. For a loaf that is only slightly past, bake it a touch cooler and accept a flatter, more open result. For dough that is truly slack and lifeless, stop fighting it: gently press it into an oiled pan for a rustic sandwich loaf, or stretch it into a tray for focaccia, where a low, airy structure is a feature rather than a flaw.

    Stop guessing for good

    The poke test cures the panic in the moment. To stop the guessing entirely, take the judgment out of your fingertips and put it into a number. Pinch off a small piece of dough at the start of the final rise, drop it into a clean, straight-sided jar, mark the starting level, and watch it climb. When that sample has risen the amount your recipe wants, the main loaf has too. This aliquot-jar trick, plus keeping a rough log of your dough temperature and proof times, turns an intuition you have to relearn every day into a repeatable target.

    A small glass jar with a rising dough sample beside a mixing bowl
    An aliquot jar turns proofing from a guess into a number you can trust.

    None of this requires a thermometer-precise kitchen or years of practice – just the habit of asking the dough instead of the clock. Flour a finger, press half an inch, and watch how the dent comes back. Once you can read that slow, gentle spring, the anxiety over when to bake mostly disappears, and your loaves start showing up tall, open, and evenly baked. The dough always knows. The poke test is just how you listen.


    Sources & further reading:

    Related Reading

  • Why Is My Sourdough Gummy? The Real Causes of a Dense, Underbaked Crumb (and How to Fix It)

    Why Is My Sourdough Gummy? The Real Causes of a Dense, Underbaked Crumb (and How to Fix It)

    You did everything right. You fed the starter, timed the folds, watched the loaf dome up golden in the oven. Then you cut into it an hour later and the middle is dense, sticky, almost raw-looking — the knife drags and the crumb smears instead of springing back. That gummy, gluey interior is one of the most common and most demoralizing sourdough problems, and it almost never means you have to start over. It means one specific thing went wrong, and once you can name it, you can fix it on the very next bake.

    This is the fix-it desk. We are going to walk the diagnostic arc: what “gummy” actually is, the real causes ranked from most to least common, and exactly how to correct each one. Grab your last loaf if you still have it — the crumb tells the story.

    Two sourdough loaf halves compared: a gummy dense crumb on the left and an open well-set crumb on the right
    Gummy versus set: a sticky, streaky center on the left, a properly baked open crumb on the right.

    First, What “Gummy” Actually Means

    Bakers throw around three words that get tangled together: gummy, dense, and dry. They are not the same problem, and mixing them up sends you chasing the wrong fix.

    Gummy is a moisture-and-set problem. The crumb feels sticky or pasty, it compresses under the knife instead of tearing cleanly, and it can look translucent or streaky near the center. Dense is a rise problem — a tight, heavy crumb with few holes, but the texture is still cooked and dry to the touch. Dry is the opposite of gummy: crumbly, thirsty, falling apart. You can have a loaf that is both dense and gummy at once, which is why diagnosis matters. For the rest of this guide we are hunting the sticky, unset, gluey interior specifically.

    Cause #1: You Sliced It Too Soon

    This is the single most common reason a perfectly good loaf reads as gummy — and the easiest to fix. When bread comes out of the oven it is still cooking. The interior is full of hot steam and the starches are only partly set. Cutting in while it is warm releases that steam, collapses the delicate structure, and the knife smears the still-gelatinizing crumb into a paste. You did not bake a bad loaf. You interrupted it.

    The fix: cool the loaf completely on a wire rack before slicing — a minimum of two hours for a standard boule, and closer to three to four hours for a large, high-hydration loaf. I know that is agonizing when it smells that good. Set a timer, walk away, and cut it cold. Nine times out of ten the “gummy” crumb was simply an impatient crumb.

    A knife smearing the sticky crumb of a warm sourdough loaf cut too soon
    Cutting in warm releases steam and smears the crumb — often the whole reason it looks gummy.

    Cause #2: It Is Genuinely Underbaked

    If you waited the full cool-down and the center is still sticky, the loaf was undercooked. Home bakers chronically pull bread too early because they judge by color or by the clock, and a dark crust can hide a raw core — especially in enriched or whole-grain doughs that brown fast.

    The fix: stop baking by time and start baking by internal temperature. Slide an instant-read thermometer into the center of the loaf; a lean sourdough is done at roughly 205 to 210 degrees Fahrenheit (about 96 to 99 Celsius). If it reads low, the inside is not set no matter how dark the crust looks. Two habits solve this for good: bake a little longer with the lid off to drive out moisture, and if your crust is racing ahead of the crumb, drop your oven 15 to 25 degrees and extend the bake so the heat has time to reach the middle.

    An instant-read thermometer probed into the center of a sourdough loaf on a cooling rack
    Bake by internal temperature, not the clock — a lean loaf is done around 205 to 210 F in the center.

    Cause #3: The Dough Was Under- or Over-Proofed

    Proof is where gummy crumb is quietly born long before the oven. An underproofed dough has not developed enough gas and structure, so it bakes up tight, damp, and often with a gummy line just above the base. An overproofed dough has exhausted its gluten, collapses in the oven, and can also set into a dense, moist crumb.

    The fix: learn to read the dough, not the recipe’s clock — kitchen temperature changes everything. For underproofing, give the bulk ferment more time and look for a 50 to 75 percent rise, a domed and jiggly surface, and a few bubbles at the edges of the container. Use the poke test: a gentle dimple should spring back slowly and only partway. If it springs back instantly you are underproofed; if it stays fully sunken you have gone too far. When in doubt on a warm day, shorten bulk and let a cold overnight retard in the fridge do the finishing work.

    Cause #4: A Young or Sluggish Starter

    Everything downstream depends on your starter, and a weak one is a hidden cause of gummy loaves. If your starter is not reliably doubling within four to six hours of a feed, it does not have the yeast population to raise a loaf in a sensible window. The dough drags, you either underproof waiting for action that never comes or overproof chasing it, and the crumb pays the price.

    The fix: get the starter strong before you blame the bake. Feed it on a consistent schedule at a 1:5:5 ratio (one part starter to five parts flour and water) in a warm spot, ideally 75 to 80 degrees Fahrenheit. Watch for a confident, predictable doubling with a domed, bubbly surface and a clean, tangy-yogurt smell — not sharp acetone or a layer of grey hooch. Only build your levain and mix a loaf when the starter is at that reliable peak. A lively starter is the cheapest insurance against a gummy crumb.

    A bubbly, doubled sourdough starter at peak in a glass jar
    A strong starter doubles in four to six hours — the cheapest insurance against a gummy loaf.

    Cause #5: More Water Than Your Flour Can Handle

    High hydration gives you that dreamy open crumb — but only if your flour and your technique can carry the water. Push the hydration too high for a lower-protein supermarket flour, or skip the gluten development, and the dough never builds enough structure to trap steam and set cleanly. The result bakes gummy and slack.

    The fix: match hydration to your flour and your skill honestly. If you are fighting gummy loaves, dial hydration back to 68 to 72 percent and get consistent results there before chasing 80 percent open crumb. Use a bread flour with 12 percent protein or higher for reliable strength. And build real gluten: a proper set of stretch-and-folds during bulk, or a short knead, so the dough passes a rough windowpane and holds its shape. Structure, not just extra water, is what gives you an open, well-set crumb.

    Wet hands stretching and folding a strong, elastic sourdough dough in a bowl
    Structure, not just extra water: proper stretch-and-folds build the gluten that sets an open crumb.

    Your Gummy-Crumb Fix-It Checklist

    Next time the center comes out sticky, run down this list in order — it is roughly most to least common:

    • Did you let it cool fully? Two-plus hours, cut it cold. Fix the easy one first.
    • Did you temp it? 205 to 210 F in the center for a lean loaf, or bake longer lid-off.
    • Was crust outrunning crumb? Lower the oven 15 to 25 F and extend the bake.
    • How was the proof? Aim for a 50 to 75 percent rise and a slow, partial poke-test spring-back.
    • Is your starter strong? It should double in four to six hours before you bake.
    • Is your hydration realistic? Drop to 68 to 72 percent and build proper gluten strength.

    Change one variable at a time, keep a short bake log, and the gummy loaf becomes a solved case rather than a recurring mystery. Sourdough is not luck — it is a set of readable signals, and you are learning to read them.

    Want to see each of these fixes in action? The full visual walk-through — cool-down tests, thermometer checks, and the poke test up close — lives on the LoafLovers YouTube channel. Grab our free sourdough troubleshooting guide while you are there, and we will send the next fix straight to your inbox. No hard sell, just better loaves.


    Sources & further reading:

    Related Reading

  • Overproofed vs Underproofed Sourdough: How to Tell – and How to Save the Loaf

    Overproofed vs Underproofed Sourdough: How to Tell – and How to Save the Loaf

    Your loaf came out wrong, and you’re staring at the crumb trying to work out what happened. Was it in the fridge too long? Not long enough? Almost every proofing failure comes down to one of two culprits – overproofing or underproofing – and here’s the frustrating part: they can produce loaves that look surprisingly similar. Both can bake up dense. Both can disappoint.

    The good news is that once you learn to read the dough instead of the clock, the two become easy to tell apart. And in most cases, the loaf in front of you can still be saved. Let’s diagnose it.

    Two sourdough cross-sections side by side, one dense, one collapsed
    Two failures, two opposite causes: underproofed and dense on the left, overproofed and collapsed on the right.

    First, What “Proof” Actually Means

    Proofing is fermentation. As wild yeast eats the sugars in your flour, it produces gas, and that gas inflates the network of gluten you built during mixing and folding. Get it right and the dough is light, airy, and full of tension – ready to spring in the oven. Proofing happens in two stages: bulk fermentation (the long rise after mixing) and the final proof (after shaping, often overnight in the fridge).

    Underproofed means you baked before the yeast finished its work – not enough gas, not enough airy structure. Overproofed means fermentation ran too long, the gluten broke down, and the dough can no longer hold the gas it made. Two opposite problems, and knowing which one you have decides everything about how you fix it.

    The Poke Test, Done Right

    Before you bake, this is your single best diagnostic. Flour a fingertip and press gently about a centimetre into the dough, then watch how it responds.

    • Springs back quickly and fully – it’s underproofed. The dough still has plenty of tension and needs more time.
    • Springs back slowly, leaving a slight dimple – it’s ready. This is the window you want.
    • Doesn’t spring back at all, and the dent stays or the dough sighs and deflates – it’s overproofed. Fermentation has gone past its peak.
    A floured finger pressing into proofing sourdough dough to test it
    The poke test: press a floured finger in and watch how the dough answers.

    The poke test beats any timer because your kitchen temperature, starter strength, and flour all change the pace. A recipe’s “proof for 4 hours” is a guess. The dough is the truth.

    Signs Your Dough Is Underproofed

    Underproofing usually announces itself after the bake:

    • A tight, dense crumb with small, even holes and not much lift.
    • The loaf burst or tore along the side or bottom rather than opening cleanly at your score – the trapped gas found the weakest exit.
    • An aggressive, uncontrolled oven spring that split the loaf awkwardly.
    • A gummy band near the base, because the crumb was too compact to bake through.
    Cut underproofed sourdough with a tight dense crumb
    Underproofed: a tight, heavy crumb that never got the air it needed.

    If your crumb is dense and gummy specifically from underbaking, that’s its own rabbit hole – we cover the full set of causes in our guide to why sourdough turns out gummy. But when the whole loaf is tight and heavy with a clean, pale, underdeveloped look, underproofing is usually the root.

    Signs Your Dough Is Overproofed

    Overproofing looks and feels different:

    • The shaped dough is slack, sticky, and hard to handle, spreading out rather than holding a taut ball.
    • It spreads flat when you turn it out of the banneton instead of holding its dome.
    • Little to no oven spring – the loaf bakes wide and low, like a pancake with ambitions.
    • A very open but irregular crumb, sometimes with large ragged tunnels and thin, fragile walls.
    • A sharp, boozy or vinegary smell – the sign of fermentation gone long.
    Slack overproofed sourdough dough spreading flat on a floured surface
    Overproofed: slack, sticky, and spreading – the gluten has given up its structure.

    The Confusing Part: They Can Look Alike

    Here’s why bakers mix these up. A badly overproofed loaf and a badly underproofed loaf can both come out flat and dense. The tell is in the texture and the journey. Underproofed dough was firm and springy going into the oven and burst upward; overproofed dough was slack and sticky and never rose. If you remember how the dough behaved before baking – tense and lively, or loose and tired – you’ll almost always know which one you had.

    How to Save an Underproofed Loaf

    This one is the easier rescue, because underproofing is a timing problem you can still correct – if you catch it before baking. Simply give it more time: let the dough continue proofing in a warm spot (around 24-26 C / 75-78 F) and re-run the poke test every 30-45 minutes until it springs back slowly and holds a slight dimple.

    Already baked it? You can’t un-bake, but you can rescue the slices. Toast them – toasting drives off moisture and transforms a dense, slightly gummy crumb into something genuinely good. Underproofed sourdough also makes excellent croutons, grilled cheese, and bread pudding. Nothing is wasted.

    How to Save an Overproofed Loaf

    Overproofing is trickier because the gluten structure is already degraded – you can’t rebuild it. But you can still get an edible, even enjoyable, loaf:

    • Reshape gently and bake soon. If you catch it just past peak, degas lightly, re-shape with as much surface tension as you can coax, and bake right away before it slackens further.
    • Bake it flat, on purpose. Lean into it – an overproofed dough makes a fine focaccia, ciabatta-style slab, or flatbread where a low, open crumb is the point.
    • Repurpose the bake. A flat, dense overproofed loaf shines as pizza base, sourdough croutons, breadcrumbs, or the foundation of a savoury strata.

    What you can’t do is proof it longer or expect big oven spring. Once the structure is gone, it’s gone – so the win is redirecting it, not resurrecting it.

    Dial It In Next Time

    Most proofing failures trace back to temperature and attention, not luck. A few habits that end the guesswork:

    • Track temperature, not just time. Dough ferments roughly twice as fast for every 8-10 C warmer. A cold kitchen needs hours longer than the recipe says; a hot one, far less.
    • Use an aliquot jar. Pinch off a small sample of dough at the start of bulk, drop it in a straight-sided jar, and mark the level. When it’s risen by a set percentage (50-75% for most doughs), bulk is done – no more staring at the mixing bowl.
    • Do the poke test every single bake. It’s five seconds and it’s the difference between a hopeful guess and a real read.
    Floured hands shaping a tensioned round of sourdough dough
    A confident, tensioned shape is your best insurance against both failures.

    Once you can spot overproofed and underproofed on sight, you stop baking by faith and start baking by evidence. That’s the whole game – reading the dough, catching the window, and knowing exactly what to do when it drifts.

    Want to see the poke test, the aliquot jar, and both rescue methods in action? The full walkthrough lives on the LoafLovers YouTube channel, and you can grab our free sourdough troubleshooting guide – a one-page cheat sheet for diagnosing your next loaf – when you join the email list. No hard sell, just the fixes.

    Related Reading